Help me feel better about cracked pickguard

  • Thread starter JamesC01
  • Start date
  • This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links like Ebay, Amazon, and others.

JamesC01

Squier Talker
Sep 3, 2022
9
Wales
I recently noticed that the pickguard on my squier bullet (my first guitar I got 4 years ago) has a crack in it. I think I might've accidentally bumped something heavy into it a while ago, and only just noticed the crack. It doesn't look like it'll get worse on it's own, and you can't see it unless you're trying to look for it, and I could probably quite easily replace the pickguard, or even glue it back properly.
The crack doesn't seem like a problem, but sadly it has tainted my enjoyment of the guitar. I know it's silly, but I imagined that I would have my first guitar in pretty good condition with me for the rest of my life, and I'd be able to look back like 20 years from now, and still have the guitar, in fair condition. But this crack feels like it has spoiled that. I see plenty of people's guitars that they've had for years, and they're still in good condition, maybe only some mild scratches on the finish. I know it's only a squier bullet, but it was my first guitar, so I guess I'm kind of sad that the original pickguard is damaged. Part of me knows my negative feelings are irrational, since it's a tiny crack, but still. I suppose I feel worse because pickguard breaks aren't very common. If it was a scratch in the finish, I wouldn't feel too bad, but since it's such an uncommon break, I guess I feel like I'm on my own. Has anyone felt like this about one of their guitars before? Do you know any ways to get over these negative feelings and help me enjoy the guitar as is?

edit: thanks for the reassuring replies! If the crack ever becomes more of a problem, I'll likely replace the pg, but keep the original, so I at least have the complete guitar.
 
Last edited:

dpang2836

Dr. Squier
Silver Supporting Member
Jan 25, 2022
8,006
IDAHO
I would send you one if in USA! We all like to change Pickguards, but sorry yours didn't last. Get one from China. I have a Pearl White that is a match to my one ply White. Screw holes line right up which can be Rare. :cool:
 

2k5Bullet

Squier-holic
Jan 2, 2023
1,226
Palm Coast, FL
Depends upon how bad the crack is, whether it's a single or 3-ply pickguard too. Also, as with an older Bullet, maybe not the 4 year old version, but would a new one actually fit ? My 2005 has an oddity, a 10 screw hole, not an 8 or 11 hole. The 8 & 11 hole after market pickguards seem to fit Tremolo bridge Affinity fine. But the HT Bullet fixed top loader bridge is hard to find one that's a fit for a pre-made. Sometimes the screw holes are off too.

A worst case scenario, you have to fabricate your own for shape. So keep the original pickguard as your template & in as good a condition as possible. I would
think the newer 11 hole Bullet pickguards are the same as the Affinity pickguards for Tremolo Bullets & the Tremolo Only Affinity.
 
Last edited:

Uncle Joe

Squier-holic
Dec 18, 2015
4,419
Jersey
Easy fix. Don't sweat it. If it bothers you, break open the piggy bank and get a new one. Either that, or troll for dross. Some guys here have scores of unplayed guitars and parts, likely there for the asking.

I'm slightly stressed that I cracked my Squier Bullet Telecaster headstock, between the tuner holes, while I was bashing it in fireplace ashes amid creating my Joe Strummer relic/tribute. So I asked myself, "What would Joe Strummer do?" He wouldn't sweat it.
 

JamesC01

Squier Talker
Sep 3, 2022
9
Wales
PGs are cheap, why not just buy another one?
I might at some point, but it's such a tiny crack in an insignficant spot, that it shouldn't cause any problems or get worse. I guess the problem is that I'm a bit sad that I broke the original one. It's only a bit of plastic, but I guess I wanted to keep it all together as the original guitar, without anything broken.
 

JamesC01

Squier Talker
Sep 3, 2022
9
Wales
@JamesC01
I totally get how you feel!
It's ok. @blackspider57 had great advice.

I think it would be fun to replace the pickguard. Then you'll always have the original with its story. But you can give the guitar something new.
I was thinking about trying to stain the pickguard with coffee before I noticed the crack, so I may buy one at some point. I'd definitely keep the original though. Thanks for referring to the crack as part of the guitar's "story", it helps to think of it that way!
 
Nov 24, 2018
13,702
Idaho
I might at some point, but it's such a tiny crack in an insignficant spot, that it shouldn't cause any problems or get worse. I guess the problem is that I'm a bit sad that I broke the original one. It's only a bit of plastic, but I guess I wanted to keep it all together as the original guitar, without anything broken.
If it's just a little crack, I wouldn't worry about it. It's doing it's job like mentioned above and well on it's way to be a relic also mentioned above. Don't let it get you down bud.
 
Last edited:

Exhead

Squier-holic
Jul 15, 2015
2,463
Nevada
Best thing I can add is: First thing make sure all wires are neatly in the routes and not under any part of the pickguard which causes warping and other issues. When installing a pickguard and inserting screws, always put all of the screws in by hand first then when you go to drive them give them a backwards turn to center them and do not drive them all the way, drive them in just till the head starts to seat in the pickguard screw route then stop, this will assure the screw is seated properly and the pickguard is centering on all screws, then start at either screw near the bridge and snug the screws into the pickguard evenly on each side as you go up ending at the pickguard neck screws. Just snug them in, if you over tighten them this also causes the pickguard to warp and crack.
 

brians

Squier-holic
Oct 1, 2017
2,482
South Africa
Just take it as mojo and love it even more.
I get the feeling, I can also be this way, but I'm now in the place of playing my guitars and not stressing over them.
I stopped keeping them in cases a long time ago ( except my acoustic) and they get exposed to life, which means they going to take a few hits along the way.
I wouldn't change a pickguard over a small crack, you should see how worn some of mine are, and they going to stay that way, cause I'm comfortable with them.
If I do some damage to my own guitar, I'm ok with it, if someone else does it I get really pissed.

Play guitar 🎸
 

Latest posts

Top