Rich rockstars that can afford any guitar pay a big premium for mint like new vintage Fenders and Gibsons over ones that have been abused by their owners and look like s**t. What does that tell you about your reverence for guitars that have been neglected and trashed? There's no magic there. They are just hunks of wood, nothing more.To the contrary, I think what's truly special and priceless is a guitar that tells a tale of smoke filled clubs, mosh pits, groupies, bar fights, so on & so on.
The time-capsule effect of Grandpa Theodore's vintage axe found under his bed after he passed is of high thrill to some. Then it's all valuable & stuff and nobody's allowed to so much as handle it lol. Personally when I get anything shiny & new in life, I can't wait for it to not look shiny & new, so I don't have to feel fussy about it. My two cents that may be adjusted for inflation